http://enpan.blogspot.tw/2014/04/blackberryiphone.html(Blackberry贏了iPhone附掛鍵盤的禁制令)
http://enpan.blogspot.tw/2014/01/blackberry.html(產品、行銷、專利、商標與訴訟(談Blackberry模糊的訴訟策略))
當Typo Keyboard被告侵權,而且還取得禁令且輸了訴訟(Typo因持續販售而繳交罰金約86萬美元),仍進行一些改變且持續販售:Typo2 Keyboard,不過面對Blackberry"手機鍵盤"上既深且廣的專利佈局與使用者印象,這回提出告訴除了專利侵權外,還主張Typo2侵害Blackberry的外觀商標("Trade Dress",Blackberry未註冊),也就是侵害大眾在Blackberry一些產品線上的經典認知。
註(http://enpan.blogspot.tw/2012/08/trade-dress.html、http://enpan.blogspot.tw/2009/04/trade-dress.html):
Trade dress是泛指一個產品的外觀,包括產品的包裝,也可說是保護一個消費者心目中的形象,或對產品認同的信心,防止消費者因為「辨識」混淆而產生錯買的事情。Trade Dress是透過一系列專利、產品與行銷所產生的印象,明顯的如Apple的iPhone, iPad, iPod,Blackberry一系列產品也形成類似的印象。
參考:
TMEP1202.02 Registration of Trade Dress
When an applicant applies to register a product's design, product packaging, color, or other trade dress for goods or services, the examining attorney must consider two issues: (1) functionality; and (2) distinctiveness....
訴訟資訊:
法院:北卡地院
原告:BLACKBERRY LIMITED
被告:Typo Products, LLC.
被告產品:Typo2 Keyboard
訴狀內列舉2007年、2013年黑莓產品,並引用許多報章雜誌的報導,並說明Typo明知故犯,希望藉此形成一個影響陪審團"蓄意侵權"決定的氛圍。
鍵盤比較:
相關專利列舉:
US8162552
1. A keyboard for a wireless handheld mobile communication device, the keyboard comprising:
a keyfield comprising a plurality of depressible
keys arranged in rows that are distributed about a vertical centerline
of the keyboard; and
each of the depressible keys has a top
engagement surface of which an upper inboard portion is raised relative
to a lower outboard portion thereof, wherein the top engagement surface
of at least some of the depressible keys has a generally inclined crest
shape with a top of the crest diagonally oriented on the key.
US8493322
US8431849
1. A keypad assembly comprising:
a) a dome configured to operatively engage a switch sensor;
b) a dome overlay guide adhered to the dome;
c) a key corresponding to the dome, and configured to operatively engage the dome;
d) a light emitting source configured to emit light;
e) a reflector layer configured to reflect light escaping the dome overlay guide;
f) wherein the dome overlay guide is configured to receive the emitted light and direct the received light toward the key.
US8658925
1. A keypad assembly comprising:
a) a dome configured to operatively engage a switch sensor;
b) a dome overlay guide adhered directly to the dome;
c) a key corresponding to the dome, and configured to operatively engage the dome;
d) a light emitting source configured to emit light; and
e) wherein the dome overlay guide is configured to receive the emitted light and direct the received light toward the key.
US7417565
1. A hand-held electronic device comprising:
a keyboard, said keyboard having a plurality of
keys of identical shape, each key having a substantially flat contact
surface extending between a first side and an opposed second side of
said each key, said first side having a substantially planar upper
portion meeting said contact surface at an obtuse angle; said second
side having a substantially planar surface meeting said contact surface
at substantially a right angle; said keys oriented such that, for each
of a plurality of pairs of adjacent keys, said second side of one key of
each pair faces said first side of an adjacent key of each pair.
新聞來源:
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/blackberry-dials-up-second-lawsuit-774312
訴狀:
Ron
沒有留言:
張貼留言